Christian albums I still like

In high school, all I listened to was Christian music. That was because it was all I had been exposed to. My parents did not like me listening to secular stuff, and I think that wasn't necessarily a bad thing during my formative years. But as I got older and started exposing myself to different non-religious kinds of music, I stopped listening to the Christian stuff. The main reason for that the secular stuff is just better. Not to say that all christian music is bad... some may even be just as good... but very little is better. For the most part, believers just content themselves with imitating, not creating. The Christian music industry replicates every musical and production value the secular music has and adds Christian lyrics. It has all the shallowness of mainstream pop but with clean lyrics. In fact it is more shallow, because not only does it imitate a shallow thing, but it pretends that by adding generic Christian lyrics that it becomes good. That's like putting a garnish on a Mc Donalds value meal and calling it healthy.

So I began to listen to secular stuff because it was the only stuff with any level of authenticity and originality. It was going somewhere. And when I listened to old stuff, it had gone somewhere, it had forged a new path and was original. It had that intangible... art... to it that the stuff sold in Family Bookstore did not. But recently I have begun to rediscover little gems that I had thrown out with the rest of the stuff. I'll share a couple of in in detail and maybe enumerate some more at the end.

Mezzamorphis by Delirious: This is a controversial one because it is one of those albums that was discarded by the Christian community as a whole when it came out and most people still don't like it. Delirious was a worship band. This CD was a rock album. And even a worse sin for the worshipmongers, it was experimental and abstract. It was a record at the forefront of where rock was going in Britain. If you listen to it and listen to the kinds of rock that soared up the charts in the early 00's you will notice the similarities, but Delirious was ahead of the game. Sadly, they freaked out with the way this CD was received and tried to copy their earlier stuff and then later copy the stuff that was on the market. But this one album does shine for me.

Self-titled Jars of Clay album: This album has retained much of its timelessness. With their debut album, Jars of Clay showed the music community a new sound. The tremendously acoustic instrumentation was contrasted by the high production values. Sampling was used on top of crisp acoustic guitars and strings and rich vocal melodies were heard once more in an era dominated by new-wave punk and ska and post-grunge rock. And while it had enough straightforward Christian lyricism (in songs like "Faith like a child" and "Love song for a savior") to attract mainstream Christians, it also had many songs filled with poetic words that relied on symbols and abstract imagery.

Smell the Color Nine, by Chris Rice: I am not sure why I like this Chris Rice. I think it is because of his simplicity. His music is quite simple most of the time, though some of the arrangements are a bit otherworldly at times. His lyrics come dangerously close to being cheesy at times. But that is the appeal. While they do go a bit overboard at times, it is his sincerity that pulls it through. His starry eyed views of God aren't all rainbows and butterflies. He is a doubter, a desperate human being. That's what sets him apart from 99% of the others out there. His voice expressive voice is able to pull emotions that have so often been overdone in music (angst and love) and turned them into something that is still human.

High Noon by Mark Heard: Now here is a guy most of you have never heard of. He was from the late 80s, and really he never became super huge back then either. His music is remarkably undated, due probably to the fact that he was playing a sort of style that today would be called Alt. country rock. He never quite fit in, hanging in the gap between Christian and secular in a style that would take the world another decade to begin to understand and appreciate. Probably one of my favorite lyricists secular or Christian.

There are other albums that I can actually take seriously again, like (surprisingly) Take me to Your Leader, by Newsboys (it is the only one of their that is worth anything), Kansas by Jennifer Knapp, Legend of Chin by Switchfoot (their most secular and rocky album, and the only one that is good really). Then I have to admit that I have a soft spot for many early Christian music artists, those that came out before there was an industry pumping out God's music. I mean people like Keith Green, early Michael Card, Larry Norman... They are generally really cheesy, but they were groundbreakers, singing music styles they liked (that many churches banned) about things that they cared about, it just happened to be that the thing they cared about the most was God. There is a certain uncompromised feel about their music that most groups have lost today. Today most Christians musicians interested in making good music actually go secular. Kind of sad that the christian led music industry has become so shallow that Christians have to go to the secular guys to make something with any depth. And many of the ones that should be hailed as prophets because of their strong criticisms (I'm thinking of people like Pedro the Lion and rebukes are being demonized. Its a shame. But every now and then, one can find diamonds in the rough.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Buy Ryan, you left out our mutual favorite: Carmen! How could you forget him?
Anonymous said…
I think you may have also forgotten Kirk and the fam? I know that you gave all of your albums to me when I transferred, but I thought you might need a reminder?? Don't forget that I burned you a few copies. They are in your CD case, behind your collection of NKOTB.
Anonymous said…
Yes, I think that all you have said it´s true, but ¿What is the real problem?
On the other hand ¿Which is your position about secular music which conteins christian messages?
Anonymous said…
yep. it's sad to see that they're all answering to the demands of the mainstream culture. but i guess it's all about money.. for all of them. unfortunately so.
go pedro.
Anonymous said…
thanks ry you're a sweetie (thanks for the compliment about my blog being worth reading). Actually i keep trying to post but blogger hates me or something.
Anonymous said…
I'm glad you mentioned some of the old-school guys at the end, I was about to point that out. If you think about it, its not that tragic. At the end of the day, as you said, teenagers listen to pop kind of music, not adults (yes, you are now considered an adult in my book, and yes, that means if an adult is in love with crap pop (not original interesting stuff, but crap, please understand (and pop in this case would include certain kind of pseudo R&B boy bands and the such, as well as much of the hip-hop, I use pop for lack of a better word for mainstream crap))). So who pays for these CD's? There are some people in the shadow who don't care about what ideas get out there, they fund it, but the consumer actually buys, who are these consumers? Yes, the parents. Therefore, this kind of mainstream music actually is marketed to the parents, be it Christian or not. Christian parents want their kids to listen to Christian stuff, non Christian parents something else (perhaps, or they don't find it important). Therefore there MUST be this kind of music. I find both repugnant, but if my younger sibling or daughter wanted to listen to this kind of music I would prefer her to listen to a good message, not caring about the quality of music (not in the case of my little sister, who happens to know more about music than me...).
In adult music, since it's more about idol worship (in the sense of worshipping the artists) it's harder to find a Christian market because we have to be careful of not overstepping the line between admiration and adoration... Very complex issues, I don't think you can simplify and generalize it as much as you did, kind of blaming these Christian artists of being imitative, I think. Art? Ha, what a concept, I'll deal with that in about 20 years if I'm lucky enough to form an opinion.
Anonymous said…
true true... but I still think there is something remarkably nauseating about the christian industry copying such shallow forms.... but yeah. complex stuff when you get down to some of the details.

Oh I forgot to add Sixpence None the Richer's eponymous album. That was a quality CD.
Anonymous said…
I would agree with all your albums but add a whole lot more of woship albums. The problem with any worship album is that, if it's made for people to sing along, it has to contain songs with a pretty basic structure, a more "commercial" approach, otherwise it turns into something else. But in that structure, some bands have gotten a deep sincerity and something I might call anointing, even a creative anointing to somehow come out of the speakers when playing it, these I can listen to again and again. For example:
Most of 100 Portraits (although most of it isn't worship) including Enter the Worship Circle (particularly, the first).
Waterdeep "Everyone's Beautiful" and other songs.
Third Day "Offerings" (I didn't like the other two).
Delirious "The Cutting Edge"
Marcos Witt "Enciende una luz" (don't laugh, I really think it was a great CD).
Probably more, but you've already lost all your musical respect for me so I'll give up.
Anonymous said…
no, I was thinking of doing another list for worship CDs of sorts... I generally despise most worship CDs and the industy that makes them. Hillsong makes me retch. But I have to admit that some albums are true and honest attempts to connect with the almighty and to lead others into a simlar connection.... so here is my list of CDs I can worship to (some of which I agree with you kenny) Some of you will question my traditional ones while others will call me untraditional for some of my choices no doubt:

-The first enter the worship circle CD
-Delirious "The Cutting Edge"
-Aradhna, "Deep Jale" is good, but I think marga darshan is better still.
-my gregorian chant CD from Silos is friggin sweet.
-Andy Hunter "Exodus"
-David Crowder Band "Can you hear us"

.... and believe it or not, many Ben Harper and Bob marley songs have similar effects on me, though no album as a whole.
Anonymous said…
Yes, I forgot to mention David Crowder.

Popular posts from this blog

Things I think in the city on the verge of winter

Snowmelt demands movement

Blogs